In 1957,Vajpayee's remark on Kashmir policy - "Hum Yudh jeeth gaye, sandhi har gaye, ab kashmir ka 1/3 hissa pakistan ke saath hain" In 1957 about peace with Pakistan "Main Shanti chahta hoon lekin kabristan ki nahin, jeevan ki. Aap agar yudh se bhagenge, to yudh aap ke peeche bhagega, par woh jo dhairya se yudh ka saamna karega woh na sirf apni hak ki raksha karegaa, shanti bhi sthapith karega" Dec 1997 to Times of India - "Sawaal yeh nahin hain ki pradhan mantri kaisa ho, sawaal yeh hai ki desh kaisa ho" Parliament in 1961- "If we have reservation in services on the grounds of religion, national spirit will never grow in the country. Will you ask someone his religion before giving a job?

Thursday, March 20, 2008

A permanent friendship in an unfriendly profession

Politics is a game of shrewdness and smartness. It is a game where everyone's aim is to grab power and each pursues a different agenda to achieve it. There are no permanent friends or enemies in politics and is definitely the dirtiest profession. However, it is ironically the most effective means of bringing in rapid changes that affect lives of a country or state. Many times when we have to clean the sewage we need to get into it. This is not a mandatory requirement in cleansing dirt,but surely an effective and time tested one. So is the profession of politics. In such an unfriendly atmosphere where every relation is made or broken for greedy purposes, one can rarely expect a true friendship to exist.

India, post independence has seen 2 such friendship relations. One, Nehru-Sardar, and the other Vajpayee-Advani. The timing of presence of both these pairs has changed our country in many ways, both for the better and worse. Although this article is not to highlight the Nehru-Sardar relationship, it is definitely to highlight the other example.

Both being RSS members and having served the public life for 50 years, there is no match for Advani and Vajpayee. Both have seen the most turbulent and smooth sailing times. They have faced a lot of events, disasters both in opposition and in power. What however remains an inspiration to all true friends is the understanding these two shared. I am waiting to read the book by Advani -"My country My life" not just to learn politics,but also to understand "a case of friendship in an unfriendly profession".

Leave apart the excerpts from the book, let me tell you that both these tall leaders did have differences in opinion over Modi, Kandhahar Hijacking, Ayodhya, etc. Differences must come in friendships so that they become stronger. But they never made them public (It is only now Advani has written because many people pressurized him to say what he feels about his friend Vajpayee). They conducted themselves in such a disciplined manner that their own partymen must learn from it. They never split their relationship nor the party. Even when Vajpayee was to be chosen as PM in 1996,1998 and 1999, Advani could have raised a rebellion because it was he who brought BJP to power. He never did so. He trusted his friend and he(Vajpayee) was the most acceptable face amongst all parties supporting it. Their own party people were divided between these 2 leaders in 2003 and post 2004 debacle as to who should lead. Despite all this, Advani and Vajpayee never lost temper nor accused each other of anything. They were matured and seasoned enough that they handled such situations in an audacious manner. If power was the only reason, Advani must have broken the relationship with Vajpayee after NDA defeat in 2004. He never chose to do so. Some blamed Vajpayee for Muslim appeasement while some for ignoring Hinutva by Advani. But these blame games were never done personally by both of them. Even during this crisis, their friendship never withered. Be it emergency, loss of power for 2 times (1979 and 1980's), they never cared for power at the cost of their friendship.

Advani said in a speech,"3 things that made the world look around India are 1) continuation of democracy 2) Ending of license permit raj and hence opening up of indian economy by Narasimha Rao 3)Pokhran II by Vajpayee". This statement reflects the openness of a leader who accepted the rival parties achievement and also that of his own colleague. Advani never told to anyone or any public forum that it was he who brought BJP to power and hence has the right to become PM. On the other hand it was Vajpayee who once stated that the next PM candidate is Advani. The media made a hue and cry about it and created a rift that never existed. Both leaders even at that time were strong and their bonding was never shaken. They always discussed, came to a consensus and then swung into action. This sort of seeking clarity amidst confusion and differences is unparalleled in Indian politics. Even sardar and nehru did not discuss many times because they did not share a close rappo as much as Advani-Vajpayee share.

Some of the friendships in politics which have vanished into a vacuum for the sake of power include Tony Blair-Gordon Brown, MGR-Karunanidhi, Deve Gowda and Siddaramiah and many others. What is unique to these two is that they have always found to clear their differences through discussions . In one of the excerpts I read, Advani says that he could make out anger and happiness from Vajpayee's face and vice versa and then the first thing they did was to sit down and analyze why.

Advani openly admitting that Vajpayee is truly his mentor, his leader and his inspiration cannot be simply done just for any gains for this statement by advani was made both in power and in opposition. Similarly Vajpayee admitting that he is a much misunderstood man and he is an all time comrade and colleague is a further confirmation from the other friend.

What else is more required for a friendship to sustain? Not how they stand in happiness, but in sadness and darkness. Both Vajpayee and Advani are living legends and testimonies to Indian politics post 1947. Their political life is as big as an ocean where they saw deadly sharks and friendly dolphins swim together. Their personal friendship is also as deep as an ocean, not the one that has abyss at the bottom, but one that has endless trust and understanding.

Today, I feel that this unfriendly profession has given me a role model of true friendship. All True friends in the world must at least appreciate that we have a living example of a strong friendship from a profession that breeds enmity, jealousy and hypocrisy. Perhaps as Lord Krishna said- "Learn to be like a lotus that stands unmoved and untouched by the dirt in which it grows", Vajpayee and Advani's friendship is the lotus that will continue to stand amidst the filthy politics forever, untouched and unmoved. Their party symbol is perhaps the symbolic representation of this friendship.



4 comments:

sunjam said...

very well written article...exposes good facts, plus a gr8 relationship still sustaining n infact getting stronger each day in this dirty world of politics..anybody who understands the meaning n importance of having a best friend will appreciate this blog even more...did u get me Mr. Rising Citizen...guess who??? :)

RisingCitizen said...

Yea..I got who you are...And I glad that you left a comment..

RisingCitizen said...

Seena's comments:
As much as I appreciate your articles and information on Vajpayee, i will never understand the fanaticism u have towards Vajpayee.

As they say, too much of anything is bad for you, even something as simple as water! Vajpayee is almost 85yrs old, it seems like you would want him to lead India again? What India needs is not someone who is "bygone" but someone who will understand the current times and situations and who has the energy to face world politics today! There is a huge difference between two people born in two different times in history especially in their thinking, principles, mindset, actions etc. There will be two generation gaps among people and their leader!

I will not deny that Vajpayee did an excellent job and has, in his reign, taken India in a new direction.

It is interesting that you call Vajpayee "Bhishma pitamah of Indian politics" - Trust me... if Bhishma were to be living in this generation, he would not and could not have handled it and would have wanted to die much sooner than he would have liked :)... Just saying that, times have changed enormously from when I was growing up to now and things will not and should not remain the same !!

Keep us updated about the current situation in Indian politics rather than taking us back to Vajpayee and Advani who are bygones. The next face of BJP will be Modi... Give us (most of us are not aware of Indian politics as much as you) an insight on what this man is all about and what you think !

Just a suggestion.


My reply:

Hi Seena,
Thank you for appreciation and suggestions. You never understand the fanaticism I have towards Vajpayee and you also never see I have an equal amount of fanaticism towards Indira Gandhi . Both these leaders defined india. So, my blog is just to highlight the compulsions and policies of the yesteryears and how India was taken in a new direction.A person like Vajpayee should not be seen in just 6 years of NDA rule, but somebody who has seen 50 years of India as an Opposition leader. I am trying to highlight how we have come through various issues so that one can get an insight why we still have certain problems unsolved. As it is said, until you understand history, you will not know how to chart the future. You and I know a lot, but not many know about how Indira Gandhi and Vajpayee changed India-both for the good and bad and why they failed. Their failures at crucial issues give rise to paths that one must go to solve some of india's worst problems. If you personally look at the speeches of both IG and ABV, you will never say they are old at all...They are still and full of new ideas..A old man 85 years old took India in a new direction..a testimony to the fact that old people can also lead the young generation very well...Which is what my blog on Vajpayee is all about. However, that doesn't rule out that young leaders do have better ideas and should therefore be at the forefront.

Having said so, for current events, you can always keep looking at my other blog - http://risingcitize n.blogspot. com
Yes, I will be posting possible solutions to existing problems our country is facing. One blog takes you to the past and one to the current (and also future) so that we can compare the two.

I never called "Vajpayee as Bhishma Pitamah"...He has always been referred to by this. I just used that expression. For me, Bhishma is someone who apart from everything else also silently witnessed Draupadi being disrobed and Vajpayee was silent when Gujarat was burning.

Your statement seems a little exaggerated that Bhishma would die if he lived in this generation. I don't see a difference in Duryodhana then and many Duryodhans living now. Hence Bhishma would have lived until a ruler like Yudhistir would lead the country.

Yes, definitely on Modi I will be soon coming with posts on my risingcitizen blog. His speech at Chennai poses a very interesting solution to existing problems and his governance is the best example one can have today. I will put this on my blog too..

Unknown said...

That is the charisma of avb that someone of my generation is missing him today so badly